The UniverseAnswer
Can a Planet Orbit Two Stars?
Two stars can circle each other while a planet travels around them both. Astronomers confirmed it by watching the moving stars dim.
THE QUESTION LIBRARY THE UNIVERSE
Could the edge of a black hole be less perfect than Einstein’s math says?
What gravitational-wave echoes might reveal about black-hole boundaries, why quantum structure is unconfirmed, and what a convincing detection needs.
THE SHORT ANSWER
Possibly, but a proposed departure needs a measurable prediction and reliable evidence. Some compact-object models predict delayed gravitational-wave echoes. An unusual signal would need careful checks and comparisons before it could identify a new physical mechanism. The answer depends on what observations support, rather than on how striking an idea sounds.
- A horizon is a boundary, not a photographed material surface.
- Echoes are predicted by some alternatives, not all quantum-gravity theories.
- The cited GWTC-4.0 searches did not establish post-merger echoes.
WHAT WE DON’T KNOW YET
Whether horizons have observable quantum structure remains unresolved. Negative searches constrain particular signals; they cannot exclude every alternative.
WHAT WOULD CHANGE THIS ANSWER
A robust signal with the predicted timing and waveform, surviving independent noise and modeling checks and discriminating among specific alternative explanations.
Possibly, but a proposed departure needs a measurable prediction and reliable evidence. Some compact-object models predict delayed gravitational-wave echoes. An unusual signal would need careful checks and comparisons before it could identify a new physical mechanism. The answer depends on what observations support, rather than on how striking an idea sounds.
THE LONG ANSWER
THE LONG ANSWER · ABOUT 2 MINUTES
You’ve read your 3 free long answers this month.
The short answer, how sure we are, what we don’t know, what would change our mind and every source stay free on every page, for everyone.
All Access members read the long answer: the evidence piece by piece, the strongest objections, and how to check it yourself.
Join All Access · $1 a week Or $6 a month
Billed $52 once a year. Cancel anytime in your account.
Until December 4, 11:59 pm Pacific: the Founding rate is $39 a year, and it stays $39 while you stay a member.
Create a free account: 6 long answers a month, email only.
Paying never buys a different answer. Our Paywall Promise
Keep asking
New here?
God Plays Dice answers big questions in plain words, with sources and one of six honest labels.
Words worth knowing (3)
- echo
- A proposed delayed pulse following a main gravitational-wave signal.
- reflectivity
- How much of an incoming disturbance a model sends back outward.
- Planck scale
- A scale associated with combining quantum physics, gravity, and light speed.
Sources & further reading
(4) · Checked Oct 5, 2026
- Anatomy of a Black Hole ↗NASA ScienceThe event horizon is distinguished from radiation produced by surrounding matter.
- A recipe for echoes from exotic compact objects ↗Mark, Zimmerman, Du and Chen; Physical Review D2017 theoretical model uses a simplified wave field to examine reflected delayed signals; it reports no observed horizon structure.
- GWTC-4.0: Tests of General Relativity. III. Tests of the Remnants ↗LIGO Scientific, Virgo and KAGRA CollaborationsMarch 2026 preprint: no echoes in searched events; combined ringdown deviation weakens with added GW250114.
- Comments on: "Echoes from the abyss: Evidence for Planck-scale structure at black hole horizons" ↗Ashton and colleagues; original research responseDecember 2016 methodological preprint challenges the analysis and significance of an earlier echo claim; it is not a new detector observation.
See a mistake? Report a problem. Corrections are made openly.
CONTINUE THE THREAD
Where this question leads.
The UniverseAnswer
What Is the Higgs Field, and Why Call Its Particle the “God Particle”?
An everywhere-present field, a fleeting particle and a famous nickname. What did CERN’s experiments actually measure?
The UniverseAnswer
Why do physicists still call the matter-antimatter imbalance unsolved?
Why the matter surplus remains unexplained, what Sakharov's conditions require, and how sphalerons and proposed neutrino mechanisms might connect.